I was sitting at my kitchen island at 28 weeks pregnant with my first, staring at my phone as three completely different realities collided in my text messages. My grandma was insisting we rent out the church fellowship hall for a women-only afternoon of cucumber sandwiches and a mandatory dress code. My college roommate was pitching a co-ed "Baby-Q" featuring a keg and a brisket. Meanwhile, my Pinterest algorithm had aggressively decided I needed to construct a twelve-foot, hand-tied pastel balloon arch that would cost more than my monthly mortgage payment. I'm just gonna be real with you, I closed my phone, ate three string cheeses over the sink, and cried.
Planning a baby shower is a deeply weird experience because everyone projects their own baggage onto your unborn child. You're exhausted, your ankles look like rising dough, and suddenly you're supposed to play cruise director for thirty of your relatives while pretending to be thrilled about receiving your seventh embroidered burp cloth. Honestly, sometimes these old-school events feel less like a party and more like a literal baby show where you’re the prize heifer at the county fair, just sitting there while people inspect your midsection.
Now that I'm on the other side of this circus with three kids under five, I've some thoughts on how to throw a shower that doesn't make everyone want to fake a family emergency to get out of it.
Let's talk about the guest list and that weird old etiquette
You know that old Southern rule that family members shouldn't host the shower because it looks "gift-grabby"? Bless their hearts, but the people who invented that rule probably owned homes that cost $12,000. We're living in an economy where diapers require a financing plan, so whoever has the energy and the venue to throw this party should absolutely do it, no apologies needed.
When folks ask me for baby shower ideas for girls or baby shower ideas for boys, I tell them the exact same thing: ditch the hyper-pink "princess" or aggressive blue "construction" themes, invite the dad's friends too, and just feed people well. The co-ed shower was the best boundary I ever set. My husband helped make half this baby, he can absolutely sit next to me and act surprised when we open a nasal aspirator. Plus, having the guys there somehow dilutes the intense, interrogating energy that sometimes happens when thirty women corner a first-time mom to ask about her birth plan.
Oh, and if this is your second or third kid, don't let anyone guilt you into a "Baby Sprinkle"—just ask your friends to drop off some size 2 diapers and maybe a frozen lasagna and call it a day.
Games that won't make your friends fake a stomach bug
I need to go on a tangent here because I'm still traumatized by my oldest child's baby shower. Some well-meaning aunt decided we were going to play the game where you guess the circumference of my pregnant belly using a roll of toilet paper. I was already feeling huge and hormonal, and having a room full of people loudly estimate my girth while tearing off massive chunks of two-ply sent me straight into the bathroom for a quick sob. It's a terrible game. Burn the toilet paper.
And don't even get me started on the melted chocolate bar in the diaper game. Who thought of this? Why are we forcing our adult friends to aggressively sniff a mashed-up Snickers out of a Huggies newborn diaper on a Sunday afternoon? It's repulsive, it's weirdly degrading, and I refuse to participate.
If you want people to actually enjoy themselves while helping you out, just combine your games with practical bribery by running a diaper raffle where everyone who brings a box of wipes or diapers gets a ticket for a decent gift card, and set out some plain newborn onesies with non-toxic markers so people can chat while making something you'll actually use.
The registry trap and what you actually need
Here's the truth about baby gear: ninety percent of it's designed to appeal to the parents' anxiety rather than the baby's actual needs. With my first, my living room looked like a plastic explosion. I had swings that vibrated, bouncers that played tinny classical music, and so many flashing lights my house felt like a Vegas casino.
By the time my second rolled around, my brain was so fried I just begged my mom for quiet things, and she ended up getting me the Wild Western Wooden Baby Gym from Kianao. I'm telling you, this thing genuinely saved my sanity during those brutal 4 PM witching hours. It doesn't need batteries, it doesn't play that one electronic song that will haunt your nightmares, and it's genuinely pretty to look at. It's just a simple wooden A-frame with these little crocheted horses and wooden buffalos. My doctor made some passing comment once about how babies can get overstimulated by too much plastic flashing garbage, and whether that's hard science or not, I can absolutely confirm my son would lay under this wooden gym and just peacefully bat at the little cactus for twenty minutes while I inhaled a cold cup of coffee.
When you're building a registry, you're also going to get roughly one million blankets. People love buying blankets because they're cute and don't require knowing anything about car seat safety standards. I've a stack of them in my Etsy workspace right now. Some are scratchy, some shrink into weird little squares when you wash them, but the Organic Cotton Pear Blanket is honestly pretty decent. I'm usually pretty cynical about the whole "organic" label, but apparently conventional cotton is sprayed with an ungodly amount of chemicals, so I guess it's nice knowing this one is GOTS-certified. It's just a good, soft, double-layered blanket. It won't change your life, but it washes well and the yellow pear print is cheerful without being obnoxious, so if someone's gonna buy you a blanket anyway, put that one on the list.
Advice cards are mostly garbage but here's what helps
Every shower has that little station where guests write advice on cardstock. If I had a dollar for every card that said "Enjoy every single moment, it goes so fast!", I could have hired a night nurse. That phrase is toxic positivity wrapped in a pastel bow. You're not going to enjoy the moment your baby has a blowout up their back in the Target parking lot while you're running on two hours of sleep. Telling a new mom to enjoy *every* moment just sets her up to feel immense guilt when she inevitably hates 3 AM.
The best advice I ever got on a shower card was from a mom of four who scribbled: "It's perfectly fine to put a screaming, fed, changed baby safely in their crib and walk outside for five minutes to look at a tree and breathe."
There's also so much conflicting medical advice floating around these parties. Your great-aunt will tell you to put rice cereal in the bottle at two weeks old so they sleep (don't do this), and some crunchy influencer friend will tell you to bed-share from day one. Dr. Miller, my doctor, sat me down and said the AAP recommends just keeping the bassinet in our room for the first six months because it apparently lowers the SIDS risk, though honestly trying to parse through all those sleep studies just makes my postpartum brain glitch. I just nod, put the baby in the bassinet next to my bed, and try not to spiral into Google black holes at midnight.
Feeding your people without needing a second mortgage
Please don't feel pressured to hire a caterer. No one genuinely cares about perfectly piped miniature cupcakes or culturally vague chicken salad scooped into phyllo dough cups. We live in Texas. We ordered a massive tray of enchiladas from our favorite hole-in-the-wall place down the street, bought three bags of tortilla chips, and made a giant bowl of guacamole. It cost maybe a hundred bucks and people honestly ate it.
If you're hosting an afternoon shower, just set up a massive grazing board. Throw some cheeses, crackers, grapes, and whatever else is on sale at Aldi onto a big wooden cutting board and let people fend for themselves while you sit in a comfortable chair and elevate your swollen feet.
Think past the newborn phase when making that list
Here's a rookie mistake I made: I only registered for newborn stuff. Babies are only newborns for like fifteen minutes. Before you know it, they're eighteen months old, throwing spaghetti at your face, and you realize you own zero plates that won't shatter on your tile floor.
Put toddler feeding supplies on your registry. The Walrus Silicone Plate is one of those things I wish I had asked for from the start. It has this suction base that's surprisingly aggressive—my middle child used to try to rip it off the high chair tray like he was pulling Excalibur from the stone, and it really stayed put. It's made of that heavy food-grade silicone so you can toss it in the dishwasher, and the little sections are deep enough to keep the peas from touching the applesauce, which, if you've a toddler, you know is a punishable offense. It's incredibly practical, and frankly, I’d rather get a good suction plate than another stuffed bear my kid will ignore.
honestly, a baby shower is just a mechanism to get the people who love you in one room so they can help you stock your house with expensive supplies before your income takes a hit. Keep it simple, eat the good food, tell your friends you love them, and don't let anyone wrap you in toilet paper.
Browse the feeding collection and add some toddler-proof plates to your registry before you forget.
Frequently Asked Questions About Surviving Baby Showers
Do I seriously have to open gifts in front of everyone?
Honestly, no. This is your party. Staring at 30 people while trying to drum up a fake gasp of surprise for a nasal bulb syringe is exhausting. A huge trend right now is the "display shower" where guests bring gifts unwrapped with a little tag, and you just display them on a table. Everyone gets to see the cute stuff, and you get to spend your time seriously eating the food you paid for instead of wrestling with tissue paper.
Who pays for the baby shower?
Usually the person hosting it, which is why you shouldn't let someone with champagne tastes host a party on your behalf if you know they can't afford it. If a group of friends is co-hosting, they split it. If you and your partner are hosting your own casual backyard BBQ, you pay for the burgers. There's no rigid rule anymore, just don't go into debt for a party.
How do I handle guests giving me outdated or unsafe parenting advice?
Smile, say "Oh, I'll have to ask my doctor about that!", and immediately delete it from your brain. Older relatives love to tell you to put blankets in the crib or rub whiskey on teething gums. You don't need to get into a screaming match about the American Academy of Pediatrics over the potato salad. Just nod politely and then follow modern safety guidelines in your own home.
Is it rude to put expensive items on a registry?
Put whatever you honestly need on there, but be mindful of the price points. Group gifting is a big thing now, so your coworkers might pitch in together for that high-end stroller. Just make sure you also have plenty of $15-$25 items (like diaper creams, wipes, and those silicone plates) so your friends who are on a tight budget can still get you something you'll definitely use without feeling stressed.
What's the etiquette for thank you notes?
My grandma will probably read this and gasp, but if you're extremely pregnant and exhausted, a heartfelt, specific text message is better than a generic, hastily scribbled card that gets mailed three months later. If you can manage handwritten notes, do it. But if the choice is between your mental health and a piece of stationary, preserve your sanity. If you do paper cards, make your partner write half of them. Their hands aren't swollen.
Share:
That Midnight Streaming Trap Every Tired Parent Nearly Falls For
Living With a Real Life Boss Baby: Who Is Actually in Charge?