The Truth About Baby Feet: Why Everyone's Advice Is Dead Wrong

Jess
2026-04-06T14:16:29+02:00

I swear, the minute I brought my oldest, Jackson, home from the hospital, it was open season on his toes. My mom took one look at his bare little feet on a perfectly pleasant 75-degree Texas afternoon and shrieked that he was going to catch pneumonia if I didn't put socks on him immediately. The very next day, my mother-in-law showed up with a pair of stiff, heavy, wildly expensive leather boots that looked like they belonged on a 1920s dock worker, insisting his ankles would just cave in if he didn't have heavy-duty arch support right this very second. Then I opened Instagram and saw an influencer letting her baby walk barefoot through a literal cow pasture to ground his energy to the earth's frequency. I was just sitting there on my couch, sleep-deprived and smelling like sour breastmilk, staring at my kid's chubby little flippers, wondering if I was already ruining his life before he could even hold his own head up.

I'm just gonna be real with you y'all, the amount of unsolicited commentary you'll get about your child's lower extremities is completely unhinged. Everyone has an opinion, and almost all of them completely contradict each other. Between raising three chaotic kids under five and running my Etsy shop out of a spare bedroom covered in shipping tape, I've spent an embarrassing amount of time obsessing over tiny toes. So let's talk about what's actually going on down there, because half the stuff our parents did is outdated, and half the stuff on the internet is just people trying to sell you things you don't need.

Why their feet look like little squishy pancakes

If you've ever looked at the bottom of your newborn's foot and panicked because it looks completely flat, you're not alone. With Jackson, I was convinced he had the worst case of flat feet in medical history, and I definitely ugly-cried in the shower about how he'd never be able to play sports. I dragged him to our pediatrician, Dr. Evans, literally sweating from anxiety, only for him to laugh and tell me that baby feet are basically just jelly and fat pads turning into actual bone.

From what I vaguely understood of his explanation, babies aren't born with those 26 hard little bones that we've in our adult feet. Instead, it's mostly soft, pliable cartilage, which sounds slightly gross but explains why they can shove their entire foot into their mouth without pulling a hamstring. That thick layer of fat on the bottom is there to protect the cartilage while it slowly hardens over the first few years of their life, meaning those arches probably won't even show up until they're in kindergarten anyway. I guess the bones don't even fully fuse together until they're teenagers, which honestly explains why my neighbor's high schooler is constantly tripping over his own two feet.

The barefoot debate and why socks are my mortal enemy

If there's one thing the experts actually agree on right now, it's that barefoot is best whenever safely possible. Dr. Evans used some fancy word that sounded like proprioception, which I think just means your baby's brain needs to physically feel the floor so they can figure out how to balance without falling flat on their face.

There are thousands of little nerve endings in their soles that send messages to their brain about spatial awareness, and when you cram them into thick socks or stiff shoes too early, you're basically blindfolding their feet. Honestly, instead of stressing over buying the perfect pre-walking footwear and bleaching your floors every five minutes, just let them crawl around barefoot and give their toes a quick wipe down with a washcloth before you put them in the crib.

Now, I'll say that keeping them barefoot is great in theory until it's January and your house has drafty hardwood floors. I used to rely heavily on tight little baby socks, but they either fall off in three seconds or they're so tight they leave angry red marks on their chubby little ankles. I eventually moved to footie pajamas, but I've a love-hate relationship with those, too. I'm gonna shoot straight with you: most footed outfits are terrible because babies grow so fast that their toes get jammed in the ends like little sausages, which can actually squish that soft cartilage we just talked about.

If you really want to keep their toes warm without cramping their style, I've had decent luck with the Baby Romper Organic Cotton Footed Jumpsuit from Kianao. It's just okay if you buy their exact current size because of the whole growth spurt issue I just mentioned, but if you size up, it's seriously pretty brilliant. The organic cotton is super breathable so their feet don't get sweaty and gross, and it's stretchy enough that they can still wiggle their toes naturally without that horrible restricted feeling.

(Speaking of clothing that really makes sense, you can check out the rest of Kianao's organic baby clothes if you're trying to build out a closet full of things that won't irritate their skin or fall apart in the wash.)

Let's talk about the dog licking your baby

Okay, I need to go on a tangent here because I keep seeing this incredibly specific trend on TikTok and Instagram, and it's driving me absolutely insane. You've probably seen the videos: "golden retriever kisses baby feet." It's always some perfectly curated beige living room with a gentle, angelic golden retriever softly licking a giggling newborn's toes while acoustic music plays in the background. The comments are always full of people crying over how precious and pure it's.

Y'all. Bless their hearts, but no. Just no. I've a lab mix named Buster who's the light of my life, but I also watched him eat literal deer poop out of the yard yesterday morning. Dogs groom themselves. They lick their own butts. They chew on dead things they find under the porch. The idea of letting that mouth anywhere near my infant's porous, sensitive skin makes my eye twitch.

Here's the reality of babies that the aesthetic internet conveniently forgets: a baby's foot is basically a pacifier that's permanently attached to their body. If you let your dog affectionately lick your six-month-old's feet, I guarantee you that within forty-five seconds, that exact same foot is going directly into the baby's mouth. It's not cute, it's a bacterial infection waiting to happen, so please, for the love of my sanity, wash your kid's feet if the dog gets to them.

And while we're on the subject of horrifying internet trends, if you're legitimately searching for a "baby feet foot peel" to use on an actual human infant, please step away from your phone and go outside, because those chemical acid peels are designed to burn thick calluses off adult heels and will literally dissolve your baby's brand new skin.

First shoes and the Frankenstein walk

When Jackson finally started pulling to stand and cruising along the coffee table, I remembered my mother-in-law's lecture about ankle support and dragged him to the mall. Some guy with a cold metal measuring device squeezed Jackson's foot into these incredibly stiff, heavy, $65 structured boots. We took him to the park, and I kid you not, my son stood frozen in the grass for ten minutes looking terrified, and when he finally tried to take a step, he walked like a tiny, drunken Frankenstein before face-planting into the dirt and screaming.

Heavy shoes completely throw off their center of gravity. By the time my second kid came around, I was older, wiser, and much more budget-conscious, so I completely ditched the orthopedic boot idea. Infants don't genuinely need shoes until they're confidently walking outdoors on rough surfaces that could cut their feet or burn them on hot pavement.

When you do finally buy shoes, you want something that's zero-drop (meaning completely flat) and ridiculously flexible. My absolute favorite find for this stage has been the Baby Sneakers Non-Slip Soft Sole. They look like classic little boat shoes, but the sole is so soft you can literally fold the entire shoe in half with one hand. They give the baby just enough grip on the playground so they don't slip, but the bottom is thin enough that their brain still gets those floor signals to help them balance. Plus, they're around thirty bucks, which is way more my speed, and they seriously stay on chubby feet without leaving red marks. If you want something even softer for indoor wear that looks a little more traditional, the Enchanting Baby Shoes are knit from organic cotton and function more like a structured slipper, which is great for keeping them cozy without binding their toes.

The terrifying art of trimming toenails

I can't talk about baby feet without bringing up the absolute torture that's infant pedicure time. Why do their toenails grow faster than weeds in a Texas summer? They're like tiny, razor-sharp little daggers that slice up your thighs every time you try to nurse them.

I once accidentally clipped the very tip of Jackson's skin while trying to trim his big toe when he was three months old. He barely cried, but I sobbed for an hour and made my husband do it for the next six months. Dr. Evans told me you're always supposed to cut them straight across, never curving down into the corners, because babies get ingrown toenails super easily. And you've to clean between their toes every single night, because they mysteriously accumulate this grayish-blue lint from their onesies that mixes with baby sweat to create a smell that I can only describe as tiny sour cheese.

If you're ready to ditch the stiff boots and give your baby's feet the freedom they honestly need, grab a pair of those soft-sole baby sneakers from Kianao and let those little toes breathe.

Frequently Asked Questions I Always Get From Other Moms

When should I put actual shoes on my baby?
Honestly, hold out as long as humanly possible. Unless they're walking outside on hot concrete, sharp rocks, or at a playground where you don't trust what's on the ground, leave them barefoot or in loose socks. I usually don't bother with real shoes until they're walking unassisted for most of the day, and even then, I stick to ultra-flexible, soft soles.

Are hand-me-down shoes bad for baby feet?
My mom always told me never to use second-hand shoes because they mold to the previous kid's foot, and for once, I think she might be right. Stiff shoes definitely get broken in weirdly depending on how the first kid walked, which can force your baby's foot into an unnatural position. But if you're talking about those super soft, unstructured leather or cloth booties that are basically just thick socks? I absolutely pass those down between my kids.

How much space should be at the end of their shoe?
You want about a thumb's width of space between their longest toe and the end of the shoe when they're standing up. But fair warning, measuring this is like trying to wrestle an alligator because babies instinctively curl their toes under when you push on the front of the shoe. I usually just pull the insole out (if it's removable), have them stand on it, and check the gap that way.

Why are my baby's feet always freezing cold?
Their circulation system is basically still under construction. My babies always had freezing little hands and feet, even when their chests and backs were sweaty. Unless their actual core feels cold or their lips are changing color, cool toes are usually perfectly normal and don't mean you need to immediately smother them in three layers of wool socks.